This comparison delves into the core of process automation (Foxboro, Honeywell) versus hybrid and electrical automation (Schneider Electric). It's crucial to understand that "Foxboro" is a brand within Emerson, and "Honeywell" refers to its Process Solutions division. For clarity, we'll compare Schneider Electric with Emerson (Foxboro) FBM201 and Honeywell.
This is a battle of titans in specific domains. Here’s a detailed breakdown.
1. Core Identity & Market Focus: A Fundamental Difference
Schneider Electric: A global leader in energy management and industrial automation. Its strength is a broader portfolio spanning from low-voltage electrical distribution (breakers, switchgear) to discrete & hybrid manufacturing automation.
PLC Focus: Their flagship PLC platform is the Modicon series (e.g., M580, M340, M262). They are designed for discrete, batch, and hybrid processes, and excel in applications like packaging, material handling, and machine control. Schneider's ecosystem includes AVEVA System Platform (formerly Wonderware) for SCADA/HMI and EcoStruxure for IoT architecture.
Emerson (Foxboro): A pure-play process automation leader. The Foxboro brand represents their DCS (Distributed Control System) and related instrumentation. Their DNA is in continuous, safety-critical processes.
Foxboro Focus: The Foxboro FBM203 Evo process automation system is their flagship. It's not a "PLC" in the traditional sense but a highly integrated, redundant, and secure DCS for industries like oil & gas, refining, chemicals, and power generation. Emerson's DeltaV is their other dominant DCS platform, with Foxboro FBM201 serving specific market legacies and strengths.
Honeywell Process Solutions: The other global giant in process automation. Like Emerson, they are focused on large-scale, continuous process industries and building automation.
Honeywell Focus: Their crown jewel is the Experion® PKS DCS. It is a comprehensive control and safety system for the most demanding process plants. Honeywell also offers MasterLogic series for PLC-based control, but it is often used as a subsystem or for specific skid integration within the larger Experion ecosystem.
3. Critical Distinction: PLC vs. DCS Mindset
This is the heart of your question:
Schneider (Modicon) sells programmable logic controllers. You buy a CPU, add I/O racks, and program logic. It's component-based, flexible, and ideal for fast, discrete tasks.
Emerson (Foxboro) & Honeywell sell Distributed Control Systems. You buy a pre-engineered, vendor-integrated system with controllers, I/O, networks, and operator stations designed to work as one from the start. It's system-based, optimized for complex regulatory loops, safety, and plant-wide coordination.
4. When Do Their Worlds Intersect? The Gray Area
Hybrid/Batch Processes: This is Schneider's sweet spot for competing with process vendors. A food & beverage plant with batch reactors (process) and packaging lines (discrete) might choose Schneider for its ability to handle both well under one platform (e.g., Modicon M580 with batch software).
Skid & Package Unit Control: Large process plants often have vendor-supplied skids (e.g., a compressor package). These skids are increasingly controlled by high-end PLCs (like Modicon or Honeywell MasterLogic) that then communicate via OPC UA or Ethernet/IP to the overarching Foxboro or Experion DCS. Here, Schneider acts as a subsystem supplier.
Water/Wastewater & Mining: These sectors often use a mix of fast logic and slow process loops. Both Schneider's PLC-based SCADA systems and Emerson/Honeywell's smaller DCS offerings compete directly here.
Conclusion & How to Choose
The choice is fundamentally about application domain:
Choose Schneider Electric Modicon if:
Your application is machine-centric, discrete, or hybrid manufacturing.
You need deep integration with electrical distribution and motor control.
You value open protocols and IT-friendly data access.
You are an OEM building equipment that will be installed in various plants.
Choose Emerson (Foxboro) or Honeywell if:
Your application is a large-scale, continuous, safety-critical process plant.
Plant-wide integration, historian data, and operator effectiveness are paramount.
You require certified, high-availability, redundant control and safety systems.
You are an end-user (owner-operator) building or modernizing an entire facility.
We are a professional PLC supplier, please email me if you need these items below.
henry@free-plc.com
|
abb di810 wiring diagram
|
abb di810 wiring diagram
|
1786-TPR
|
|
ci867 abb manual
|
ci845
|
IC695ACC400
|
|
4000-68713-8080001
|
abb ci867 manual
|
C98043-A7001-L1
|
|
di810 wiring diagram
|
abb ai810 wiring diagram
|
ATV31HD11N4
|
|
dsqc639 manual
|
ci867 abb manual
|
BRC100
|
|
bently nevada distributor
|
5x00497g01
|
NPCU-01
|
|
ci845
|
3bse008516r1
|
TU841
|
|
msda043a1a manual
|
ss823
|
330180-90-CN
|
Tsuen Wan,HONG KONG
